Video: Toshiba TG01 gets UK launch, we handle it again

Let's get the (lack of) surprises out of the way first: the device is based on Windows Mobile 6.1, sports a 4.1-inch resistive touchscreen display, and is the first smartphone out of the gate with the Qualcomm Snapdragon chipset running at 1GHz. For a bit of quaint perspective, we can still recall -- with great fondness -- a time when a desktop computer running at such a speed was considered advanced.

The most impressive thing about this phone is undoubtedly the way it is put together. In spite of its screen size almost impinging on MID territory, the device feels light in the hand and its thin design makes it easy to handle. The back is protected by a flexible and lightweight plastic that still has a very robust feel to it. Attention to detail is evident throughout and analogies to Kubrick's perfect black monoliths may be overstating the precision of the engineering, but not by much. You can be assured of two things: 4.1 inches are not too much for a phone, and the TG01 is built to last. Mind you, the glossy screen is right in line with an unpleasant trend among tech companies toward shiny and reflective displays. Sure, colors are richly saturated, but try watching a movie with any dark scenes in it and you will experience true immersion into the film medium -- by seeing your face more clearly than the action. Smudges also, as you will see in the gallery, come as part of the glossy screen bargain.
Toshiba has gone with a rather unique interface composed of stripes of interest, such as Phone, Media, Applications, and so on. The attempt to combine menu categorization with easily accessible submenu items is something of a hit-and-miss. On the one hand, it's useful to have one-tap access to regularly used features such as the web browser, but only three stripes can be on the screen at any one time and thus you often end up having to do a few swipes before getting to that one tap. And this is where much of the kudos earned by the TG01's external stylings is lost -- the hardware is simply not responsive enough to keep up with the intricacy of the UI. Oftentimes when trying to navigate through stripes your swipe will either go unregistered or move too far. Dialing and using the on-screen keyboard are similarly tortured experiences, but we're more willing to put those down to our crude and unrefined extremities.
Toshiba has certainly come out with a technically accomplished device: 800 x 480 resolution, HSDPA, WiFi and GPS are all packed atop a truly potent chipset, and the whole thing is wrapped inside an attractive package. Yet the overwhelming feeling after playing around with the TG01 for a while is one of frustration. The somewhat sluggish and unwieldy UI fails to properly tie together all the capabilities of the underlying hardware and the end product is a smartphone that can be said to amount to less than the sum of its parts.














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
STi @ Jul 10th 2009 8:07AM
Resistive touch screen FTL!!
DiGiC @ Jul 10th 2009 11:03AM
Yup, lost me right at Resistive
'we can still recall -- with great fondness -- a time when a desktop computer running at such a speed was considered advanced.'
Still have a 1GHz computer as a spare, 256MB RAM and some old nvidia agp graphics, remember bringing it back home and the whole street came to look at how fast it was. lol
EGOvoruhk @ Jul 10th 2009 8:27AM
You're right. Boo for precision!
cocoviper @ Jul 10th 2009 11:25AM
It's all windows mobile supports guys
Marc @ Jul 10th 2009 8:12AM
Oh my, how long will it take hardware companies to realise?
CONSUMERS DO NOT WANT WINDOWS MOBILE WITH SOME CRAP SKIN ON THEIR PHONE!
Use Android, it provides a much better user experience and is a far superior consumer platform.
I am continually infuriated withgreat hardware that is crippled with the awful WinMo user experience!
Rant over...
mgsrocks1 @ Jul 10th 2009 8:16AM
Companies will stop making Windows Mobile devices when consumers stop purchasing them. And i don't agree that Android provides a better experience. It's still a young platform and is more of a sandbox I think. Perhaps that will become true soon.
Wishmaster @ Jul 10th 2009 8:19AM
But still WinMo can do much more than android...
Dennis Kristensen @ Jul 10th 2009 8:21AM
People still buy them, because a lot of people look the front UI and haven't got the whole OS System knowledge..... Haven't met a single user of a WM system with a fake front, that haven't been REALLY disapointed....
EGOvoruhk @ Jul 10th 2009 8:30AM
So they want Android with a "crap skin"? Because everyone seems to be loving the Hero, and SenseUI
Also, how exactly is Windows Mobile "crippled"?..
GustavThelIon @ Jul 10th 2009 8:59AM
i love winodows mobile, I've been using it for years, I can see how a new user would be disappointed as it only shows its greatness after a good amount of tweaking and tinkering, but after putting that work into my Touch Pro/Fuze it runs WinMo 6.5 and does everything i want it to do, and does it exactly how i want
Its a matter of personal preference, you have to accept that, i can understand how someone would like the iPhone for its simplicity even though i don't care too much for it, and to be honest if i were ever to get a secondary phone it would be the HTC Hero just for a change of pace
grobbio @ Jul 10th 2009 7:42PM
nice ring!
ZSX @ Jul 10th 2009 8:12AM
What this really needs is an alternative UI like PointUI or TF3D. Toshiba's attempt doesn't go deep enough.
mgsrocks1 @ Jul 10th 2009 8:18AM
"Toshiba's attempt doesn't go deep enough."
That's what she said?
GustavThelIon @ Jul 10th 2009 9:01AM
yeah maybe, but to be honest TouchFlo is more flashy than functional, a good upgrade to 6.5 with windows titanium homescreen would make this thing great
MikeWard1701 @ Jul 10th 2009 11:06AM
Put WM 6.5 and Sense UI on this thing, then we're talking.
@GustavThelIon
Personally I'm not a fan of the 'titanium' today screen in 6.5 as it doesnt give me enough simultanious information compared to the 'classic' screen. Each to their own though.
4ty-phive @ Jul 10th 2009 11:41AM
I just thought that with the 1GHz processor would speed up the winmo experience. Just goes to show..the fastest processor isn't always the best. It's all about software
B-real206 @ Jul 10th 2009 8:27AM
^^^^^^ lol
Ripper @ Jul 10th 2009 8:40AM
Did you see how long it took to rotate the UI from landscape to portait!! And this thing is running snapdragon. wow.
haX0r @ Jul 10th 2009 11:55PM
What a waste of a chip to be running that crappy version of WinMo. Someone at Toshiba should have called HTC and asked them to license their HTC TP2 UI.
Wy @ Jul 10th 2009 9:12AM
It might not be very fast, it still looks faster than the current generation MSM72XX!
And omg look at that ring!
boe @ Jul 10th 2009 8:34PM
Nice phone. Too bad some idiot attached a chandalier to their finger - blocks the view of the phone in the bottom video.
riccardo @ Jul 10th 2009 9:54AM
OMG @ the waiting spinning symbol on video number 3.. can it get any worse? why not some 2bit graphics?
waste of gigaherz for real...
looieloo @ Jul 10th 2009 9:55AM
The only thing more amazing that outfitting this device with a 1ghz chip is their ability to overwhelm that powerhouse with a UI. Far out.
Gerard lenorman @ Jul 10th 2009 10:35AM
The full review by Cnet France with pics and mobile game capacity ;-)
http://www.cnetfrance.fr/produits/telephones-mobiles/toshiba-tg01-tsunagi-39701689.htm
MobileSwitch @ Jul 10th 2009 10:35AM
The not so snappy, snapdragon...... How did they get it to run so slow and sluggish?
gerard lenorman @ Jul 10th 2009 10:39AM
Other movie for TG01: http://www.cnetfrance.fr/news/mobilite/toshiba-tg01-video-39387238.htm
George @ Jul 10th 2009 12:31PM
Am I the only one who thinks the black boxes around icons looks very tacky, along with just about everything in the theme?
It looks like a lot of themes thrown together and overall looks rushed, shit, bollocks, cock, wanker
Brad Hagedorn @ Jul 10th 2009 12:39PM
So late in the game, how has Toshiba not come to realize that there are size limitations due the normal usage of phones? All other manufacturers have heeded this convergence, but the TG01 is simply too big.
http://blog.endeavourpartners.net/2009/07/02/when-size-matters/
EEEEE @ Jul 10th 2009 1:41PM
What most people don't know is that by default the processor isn't set at full power, in order to save on the phone's battery. You go into the settings and turn the processor up to full power and this thing flies through the UI.
Then it truly shows the 1GHz.
gm76 @ Jul 10th 2009 2:39PM
I, too, was wondering what power mode the device was running. Battery? Auto? Performance?
Charles Knight @ Jul 10th 2009 3:14PM
So, at a product launch, they were running the devices in power save mode and making the device appear slower than it actually is.
Want to buy a bridge?
where u at? @ Jul 10th 2009 1:31PM
Windows Mobile is seriously the Crysis of mobile phone os world.
No matter how good the hardware sounds apparently nothing can make windows mobile run as smooth as webOS. not even a 1GHz processor sheesh
Arachnid @ Jul 10th 2009 5:30PM
Uhhh.... what? Toshiba simply screwed this up. That's all there is to it. Take a look at the Touch Pro 2. Slower processor, more functional UI, and faster. This has nothing to do with Windows Mobile.
George @ Jul 10th 2009 1:40PM
THE UI LOOKS AWFUL.
WHY DO PEOPLE LIKE IT?
AT7 @ Jul 10th 2009 1:45PM
Intresting device(a bit too big for my pocket though) Not a fan of that UI at all... I'd be putting SPB mobile shell on it within minutes. That works smooth as silk even on my aging touch dual.
A7
mikesf @ Jul 10th 2009 6:41PM
Snapdragon is a very fast processor. As others have mentioned, it's the Toshiba UI that hobbles the device. Check out the TG01 running the Kinoma Play interface (virtual duplicate of the iPhone's interface).
http://www.vimeo.com/4844983
Sweet...
Derek @ Jul 10th 2009 9:21PM
its sooooooo sloooooow and unresponsive.
skooter @ Jul 10th 2009 11:24PM
the worst phone i've ever seen LOL! (^_^)
Paul c. Chapel @ Jul 10th 2009 11:33PM
This post is filled with microsoft fanboys. Everyone at engadget is a microsoft fanboy! If they don't have at least 5 post with Apple in it a day they are microsoft fanboys! This may have a bigger screen than the iPhone but the iPhone has a better OS!
robotphood @ Jul 11th 2009 2:21AM
Someone should demo it with the handful (if not more) of better interfaces out there for winmo.
Paul Chapel, why are you here, ever? Stick to iphone sites and threads. Why do people go out of their way to bash or even read about something they don't care about?
Enrike @ Aug 4th 2009 4:41PM
It's a shame the lack of support for capacitive screens in winmo, a that's my only regret, my actual phone it’s an Omnia, running winmo 6.1, SPB Shell 3, Kinoma play and Garmin Mobile XT, among others and even tough 624mhz, it runs very smooth just what I wish my phone to be. I think what people like from winmo is its flexibility, I agree that certain knowledge and research is needed, but let’s be honest, almost every smartphone user needs knowledge. It’s common to see iphone users looking for unlock, jailbreak, begging for more corporate approach, symbian users looking for signed apps, android users searching for options and webos users in the learning curvline. For me there’s not a perfect phone, just the phone that meets people’s needs, for me Omnia with winmo. Regards.