The good folks at HTC left this little gem (pun totally intended) on our doorstep today, but as cool as it sounds to have one of the world's great Windows Mobile torchbearers just drop off its hottest new handset to us like it's an extra large pepperoni and mushroom, it's a bittersweet gift at best. Why? The
Touch Diamond lacks both HSDPA 850 / 1900 and GSM 850 in its current incarnation, leaving it to cling to what 1900MHz EDGE towers it can find. That makes it an untouchable product for all but the hardest-core North Americans who are willing to throw both high-speed data and maximum signal coverage out of the window just to be able to put the pinnacle of WinMo 6.1 engineering in their pocket.
The box is... well, interesting. You've got to give them that, anyway. The outer cardboard trapezoid peels away to reveal a glossy black inner one, foretelling the polished sheen of the device itself. We recommend you stay pretty at all times when using this phone, because you'll see yourself constantly reflected at virtually every angle. Haircuts, teeth whitening procedures, clean shaves for the men, you know the drill.
Firing up the phone for the first time takes you through the typical customization procedure that owners of most Windows Mobile handsets will be well-acquainted with; it's an annoying but seemingly necessary procedure that just delays your impatient soul from exploring your purchase for yet a couple additional minutes while HTC sprinkles some flavor on the default Windows Mobile shell.
Once you get that taken care of and restart, you're presented with
TouchFLO 3D for the first time. Actually, not quite -- the phone prompts you to tap on the screen to fire it up for some reason, instead of taking you into it immediately -- but after you make it through that tap, you get to the now-famous home screen featuring the card-flip clock display.
It's right here, just one screen into exploring the fancy, graphics-heavy TouchFLO 3D interface, that you're left in awe of the display. The crispness of this thing is just not possible to convey without seeing it in person, thanks largely to a pretty ridiculous dot pitch achieved when squeezing 640 x 480 onto a screen just 2.8-inches in size.
We were struck by how deep TouchFLO 3D goes. Realistically, the average user could go weeks without ever coming across an old-fashioned Windows Mobile user interface, particularly if they're limiting their use to calling, messaging, media, and web browsing. With the exception of the browser, all of those WinMo elements have been replaced with TouchFLO-beautified ones, and the browser is sourced from Opera; as many WinMo owners already know, Opera's light years ahead of Internet Explorer Mobile in its current incarnation, and it looks simply stunning on the VGA display.
Talking about user input for a moment, we were bothered with just a hint of lag throughout the system, which made tapping on things and entering text vaguely frustrating. It's possible that HTC could fine-tune this with a future firmware release, but we're guessing that TouchFLO 3D combined with the high resolution are pushing that 528MHz Qualcomm core to its hairy edge. Another annoyance we found was the texture of the display. HTC has done a better job than some other vendors of making the majority of the shell finger-friendly, and swipe gestures are pervasive throughout the apps for scrolling menus, looking at pictures, changing albums of music, and the like. Problem is, the screen is sticky -- at least, it was for us. Even minor pressure made it difficult to swipe our fingertip over the screen, and on several occasions, we found our finger bouncing across the surface in such a way that we were accidentally actuating menu items that we didn't mean to.

Of course, gestures are just a part of the equation. If you're using this thing as your office away from the office, the keyboards are going to play a huge role in your productivity, and we think the Touch Diamond's set of them are going to really polarize users. We personally can't stand the two-letter concept introduced by
SureType, and that's the Touch Diamond's default. There are a couple QWERTYs in there as well -- one HTC's, one Microsoft's -- but the screen is too narrow for our fat fingers to get the job done on those. Naturally, your mileage may vary, and we know all sorts of folks that have no problem with SureType whatsoever.
Our hearts actually skipped a beat when we noticed that the Touch Diamond's phone settings offer the hope of reconfiguring the radio for UMTS 850 / 1900 and UMTS 1700 modes, despite the spec sheet assuring us that 900 / 2100 is how it rolls. Naivete and boundless hope kicked in, though, and we had a go at it. Bottom line: no dice. It lets you change the setting, but it ends up hooking up with EDGE anyway. Way to toy with us, guys.
So would we be queuing up for a version of this with the right 3G bands? HTC's done a tremendous job of hiding Windows Mobile 6.1's antiquated user interface, so we can put that little concern aside; what's more, it's hard to argue with the massive library of third-party software available for the platform, and for those worried about keeping their IT department happy, it's about as enterprise-friendly as they come. Physically, it's beautiful, liable to turn as many heads as any smartphone on the market today. Tell you what, HTC, we'll make you a deal: throw in 3G for both AT&T and T-Mobile, tweak the feel of the screen, and you have yourself a customer.
Either that, or we may just avoid the virtual keyboard controversy altogether and hold out for the
Touch Pro. Decisions!
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
AeonZero @ Jun 8th 2008 12:50AM
Man that this just wants to make me get one i can't wait till it comes out on Sprint. TouchFLO 3D ftw!
Anthony @ Jun 8th 2008 12:54AM
This is such a good looking phone I almost considered getting one & trading in my N95 8gb. ...almost. The Touch Pro? Now that *could* be another story.
Jordan Lee @ Jun 8th 2008 1:04AM
The best mobile I've ever seen. However, the keyboard situation worries me a bit.
Cassini @ Jun 8th 2008 1:06AM
The only problem with the Diamond series of phones, is that they'll only have tri-band GSM and dual-band 3.5G, as that just isn't good enough for this type of device these days.
Their current flagship, the Tytn II has quad GSM and tri 3.5G. So why don't the Diamond and Diamond Pro?
In comparison, the Sony Xperia X1 will have quad GSM and quad 3.5G (along with everything else), and still manages to come in thinner (albeit very slightly) than the Diamond phones.
HTC made a huge mistake. It's unfortunate they'd partially cripple such beautiful phones like that. They're going to lose a lot of sales simply because of that.
OziD @ Jun 8th 2008 1:21AM
apparently you don't live in the states.
I believe our first tastes of these devices will be of the EVDO variety.
Steven @ Jun 8th 2008 2:17AM
"as that just isn't good enough for this type of device these days."
Rubbish. Just show me what you can do more with the X1. And I don't mean what's on the features list, I mean actual use, today.
iofthestorm @ Jun 8th 2008 2:00PM
In case you didn't know, HTC made the Xperia too.
Cassini @ Jun 9th 2008 6:21AM
OziD and Steven - both of you apparently didn't understand a thing I said. And way to vote for your own comments.
@ OziD: I'm afraid you're mistaken. The Diamond series are GSM based, not CDMA based. Perhaps you failed to read the specs that Engadget has listed numerous times for these phones, which are also listed above. Or perhaps you're unaware that EVDO is a CDMA technology and has nothing to do with GSM. And what exactly do you think I said that made you incorrectly assume I didn't live in the States?
@Steven: Maybe you don't have much experience with mobile phones and the understanding of the necessity for multiple band coverage in an expanding cellular landscape. Or maybe you're so interested in these phones that you're defensive when someone criticizes anything about them because it doesn't make you "feel good". What can you do with the X1, you ask? You'll have more cellular bands. More cellular bands = better reception for both the States and overseas. Didn't you pick up on that in my initial post? And why are you mentioning "actual use, today"? Neither the X1 nor the Diamond series have been released to the masses, so what else do we have to go by, besides the spec list?
iofthestorm: Yes, I'm aware that the X1 was built by HTC. What's your point?
----------------------------------
The whole point of a "world phone" is to have all the bands available in a phone so it will function on all the bands that are in the States and in other countries overseas.
The Diamond series will only be a tri-band GSM and dual-band 3.5G phone. The X1 will be a quad-band GSM and quad-band 3.5G phone. Therefore, the X1 will be superior to the Diamond series of phones, at least in terms of cellular reception.
Cassini @ Jun 9th 2008 6:24AM
OK, one correction: Steven didn't vote for himself - my mistake.
But OziD obviously did.
Cassini @ Jun 9th 2008 7:20PM
Awwww, me get "low ranked". The sign Tarzan's words hit nerve from speaking truth. Me so sad. What ever Tarzan do now?
Play nice! Bye!
Schut @ Jun 8th 2008 1:12AM
Typing on that does not look fun.
snowenloe @ Jun 8th 2008 10:46AM
Thats why I would never strictly use a touchscreen only device, they gotta have a keypad of some sort. Give me a slider keypad or some other method of input and Im sold. Same goes for the iphone.
Benga @ Jun 8th 2008 1:16AM
Dagg... Another HTC post? Engadget is partial to whomever has something new to offer. All these non-iPhone posts make me want to turn on my non-iPhone filter. Sheesh!
OziD @ Jun 8th 2008 1:22AM
wait. so you want MORE iphone?
its going to be a sweet phone, but they have to draw the line, somewhere.
and personally i like hearing about phones that i know will be available to me soon. (as in, i'm a sprint customer.)
Ricardo @ Jun 8th 2008 10:26AM
"Engadget is partial to whomever has something new to offer",
Yeah, they should make posts about old stuff, afterall who on Earth would like to read about new products instead of old ones?
Tid @ Jun 8th 2008 10:34AM
Way to miss the sarcasm people...
STNC @ Jun 8th 2008 1:35AM
Typing isnt that bad, I have a Touch, and I still do around 6k messages a month, i've gone up since when I had a Treo with a keyboard.
So does this thing that a front facing camera as well?
Steven @ Jun 8th 2008 2:18AM
"So does this thing that a front facing camera as well?"
Yep. VGA. The main camera is 3.2 megapixels. The only thing I'm missing here is a flash.
Nomi @ Jun 8th 2008 3:30AM
The pro has it, along with a keyboard and a bigger battery.
pom @ Jun 8th 2008 1:35AM
The 'Now Famous' home clock should be credited to..
http://www.9031.com/downloads/screensavers.html
And yes, i'm well aware this screensaver isn't the first instance of a flip clock in history, but it's relative popularity in the past year or so is probably the inspiration for the clock on the HTC.
Fernando @ Jun 8th 2008 2:03AM
Airport clocks were the inspiration :P
Steven @ Jun 8th 2008 2:31AM
Nope, 1970's alarm clocks were the inspiration
JAmerican @ Jun 8th 2008 1:41AM
I own a Windows Mobile phone and I must say that I am still disappointed at the speed of this thing. I have a feeling they didn't focus on the video drivers in this device. Windows Mobile needs a complete revamp. Sadly that's impossible without getting rid of legacy application support.
Low Ranked, here I come :).
Steven @ Jun 8th 2008 2:19AM
"Low Ranked, here I come"
Well, at least you tried.
CUBSWILLWIN @ Jun 8th 2008 8:19AM
this is the first Highest Ranked I've seen since the site update, and you deserved it.
Anthony H. @ Jun 8th 2008 11:48AM
I guess you've only been looking at your own posts CUBS
roflercopterer @ Jun 8th 2008 2:13AM
I really want to see how fast it is with a clean 6.1 ROM
roflercopterer @ Jun 8th 2008 2:17AM
this and the touch pro which I am more interested in.
JAmerican @ Jun 8th 2008 2:28AM
My Dash is much faster with the stock Windows Mobile 6.1 Excalibur ROM. Even though it has the Glass UI on the home screen. But it still lags unfortunately.
roflercopterer @ Jun 8th 2008 2:33AM
exactly, so is my mogul.
I'm thinking the diamond/pro with all the extra horsepower minus the thouchflo equals blazing.
Andrew @ Jun 8th 2008 2:19AM
ew.
Jkr284 @ Jun 8th 2008 2:40AM
Well im in the UK and already have one of these on the full hsdpa speeds, and with a few tweaks as mentioned on the xda forums im laughing, video playback is super smoothe, all 2d/3d games i have tried at native 480x640 run super smooth, The touch 3d interface is super smooth with a few tweaks, the web browsing is AMAZING with opera and the high res screen. The only problem i see is the 4 gig is running out fast, but its a small sacrifice as it shits on the iphone in every other department.
AeonZero @ Jun 8th 2008 3:05AM
What performance issue.A great site to check out the diamond in action is coolsmartphone.com. The guy there does an entire week to show off all the major features and functions of the Diamond. The Diamond isn't that slow at all, mainly the zoom in and zoom out is just a bit sluggish. Not enough to effect how the phone works but its noticable, again it can't be perfect but again can't waait till this comes to Sprint.
TareX @ Jun 8th 2008 3:20AM
No widescreen, no keyboard and a finger friendly UI that is slow to finger touch.
If you change your phone every 4-5 months, get this one. If you don't, and you need a phone to last more than a year, wait for the Xperia X1 (If you're desperate for a WM phone). Xperia has a hi-res widescreen display, a slide-out keyboard, and a UI of its own (not nearly as flashy as TouchFLO 3D)
Or if your current phone is acceptable, and WM isn't a priority (and it shouldn't), wait a couple of months for the HTC Dream. It has a large widescreen hi-res display, a slideout keyboard, an iphonish finger friendly UI, and a OS just as fast "Android". The phone has been specifically designed with mobile web-browsing in mind.
TareX @ Jun 8th 2008 3:42AM
My Android wallpaper :))
http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/9205/androidwallpaperbrightvp1.jpg
Nomi @ Jun 8th 2008 3:27AM
Seriously though...wait for the HTC Touch Diamond Enhanced...it will have a spec bump and more memory :D
Nomi @ Jun 8th 2008 3:29AM
Gizmodo has problems with anything thats not Apple, I have been noticing it...specially since the iPhone came out. I read most of their articles, and other phones get shut out really quickly.
Mindaugas @ Jun 8th 2008 3:36AM
Question for those who have it or know for sure - is there a stylus on this thing?
TareX @ Jun 8th 2008 3:43AM
There is a stylus at the lower right corner.
Quikboy @ Jun 8th 2008 3:42AM
Nothing against Engadget Mobile, but why the heck isn't this covered as well on the main Engadget site? I don't like seeing posts as an advertisement for a post on another site.
I'm thinking the new iPhone coverage would swamp the main Engadget page, compared to a small link to another Engadget site.
Down @ Jun 8th 2008 4:17AM
Hi.
I'm looking to buy a phone (that is easy to use), it needs to have a really good WiFi system. It needs to be able to play YouTube videos clearly and efficiently. I've seen the Nokia N95, but that doesn't play youtube videos fast enough, and it's quite old now. Would the HTC Touch Diamond be any good for me? What other phones should I consider that are new or upcoming?
Phoenix @ Jun 8th 2008 9:06AM
This is easy to use, and it has a good WiFi system. it has a special YouTube program (shown in the 8th video (I think) on htt:// www.coolsmartphone.com ) and it works well, with even fast forwarding and rewinding via the zoom wheel.
The other phone is the Touch Pro: this with extra RAM and ROM, a MicroSD slot and a QWERTY keyboard, and a camera light, but without the 4GB flash storage.
emanuelle @ Jun 8th 2008 4:21AM
Oh geez! I hope HTC works the kinks out. We don't need another tytn ii kind of debacle again.
Yuval Tal @ Jun 8th 2008 5:41AM
I read in an Israeli review at pocketpcfreak.com that the Diamond gets really slow after a while due to memory leaks. Any info on that?
TareX @ Jun 8th 2008 5:44AM
Apparently the Diamond has an ultra-sensitive accelerometer AND an ultra-real vibration feedback.... as in this game:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEy6qM93mjw&eurl=http://blogs.zdnet.com/mobile-gadgeteer/
He says he feels the vibration at exactly where the ball hit the side of the screen. Incredible.
Syphon Filter @ Jun 8th 2008 7:22AM
That's just a trick of the mind. The vibration is simply created by use of the vibration motor (the that is used for vibrating message/call alerts).
The reason it may look/feel localised is because your mind sort of makes it up, your eyes see the point at which the ball hits the edge, the motor vibrates and your brain just makes the rest up give you the impression the vibration originated at the point of contact.
These devices do NOT have localised haptic feedback.
TareX @ Jun 8th 2008 7:55AM
Well it makes sense what you're saying. He also mentioned that the whole back appears to be vibrating.
But also, what makes the "trick" more convincing is the fact the vibrations aren't equal in magnitude. He says the further the ball travels before hitting the edge, the stronger the vibration. That's good programming there.
Andrew R @ Jun 25th 2008 7:45PM
I got to play with Immersions demo phones last year at SID and I gotta say it is VERY convincing and makes a UI keyboard a lot easier to use.
Immersion has a lot of IP around how you control the motor and the freqs used.
It's cool stuff and nice to see it making out into the wild.
OblatedSpheroid @ Jun 8th 2008 5:47AM
The box strikes me more of a trapezium, but then again I don't know what a trapezoid is...
Syphon Filter @ Jun 8th 2008 7:19AM
Hey guys,
Just reading the mini-review and basically it confirms what just about every other site out there is saying. Great device, great UI....but kinda slow.
One thing you mention is hte feeling that the screen is kind of "sticky". Just a theory, but perhaps the flim that they put on the front of the device ot protect it during shipping/transit has left a bit of a residue on the screen? When I first received my HTC TyTN II i remember the stylus feeling a little tacky across the surface, after a quick wipe of the screen it was perfect. Just a thought.
Personally, I'm waiting for the Touch Pro.