iPhone delayed in France due to unlocking laws?
We're not exactly up on our French, let alone our French telecommunications law, but we're hearing that Apple's supposed launch of the iPhone in that country is being held up by two different regulations that prevent the iPhone from being the locked-down revenue-generating machine Apple wants it to be. The first, a law passed in 1998, requires that carriers unlock any phone upon customer request -- for a fee during the first six months of a contract and for free after that. Notably, all three major French carriers -- including Orange, which was supposed to get the iPhone -- have lost lawsuits challenging this law. The second, which we're slightly less clear on, apparently requires carriers to sell both locked and unlocked phones. Tensions over the regulations have apparently strained the relationship between the companies to the point where Orange spokespeople are saying things like "the risk we're evaluating this week is that Apple crosses France off," but really, who expected Apples and Oranges to mix without someone getting a little bruised?
Read -- French unlocking law with unlocking provision at end of Article II
Read -- Les Echoes report on Apple / Orange tension
[Via The Unlock iPhone Blog]
Disclaimer: Although this post was written by an attorney, the attorney in question only met his university's foreign language graduation requirement by reciting an Eddie Izzard routine verbatim, so this post should not be considered legal advice or analysis of any kind.
Read -- French unlocking law with unlocking provision at end of Article II
Read -- Les Echoes report on Apple / Orange tension
[Via The Unlock iPhone Blog]
Disclaimer: Although this post was written by an attorney, the attorney in question only met his university's foreign language graduation requirement by reciting an Eddie Izzard routine verbatim, so this post should not be considered legal advice or analysis of any kind.




















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Wobbly @ Oct 6th 2007 12:58PM
Uh-huh-huh-huh...that's all the french i know.
Nemesis @ Oct 6th 2007 5:53PM
The problem is that the Consumers' Code [Law] in france prohibts the sell of a product tied to a service. Meaning that iPhones have to be sold both locked with a service plan by Orange as well as unlocked to this specific carrier.
1st problem: how do you specify the price of the locked and the "unlocked" (non-Orange) version?
2nd: Apparently Apple has demanded 30% of the calling revenues acquired by iPhone users from Orange. How can they claim that if the iPhone can be used with any carrier? Obviously they can't.
3rd: a parallel WORLD market of unlocked iPhones will be set up in France where Apple will no longer be able to guarantee "specific network-locked" iPhones, and from there they will be distributed all around the world, making ruins out of Apple's expectations to receive "air-time" premiums (actually percentages) and capitalizing from every carrier that distributes iPhone around the world.
lassi @ Oct 7th 2007 9:18AM
this is one of the points of failing for apples aim to gain a significant share of the mobile biz - wanting to be the lock-in king. should they have gone for regular route they could have launched all of europe at once.
but obviously, if they want 1000+ per iphone in revenues they couldn't just have sticked a 1k price sticker and expected anyone to buy it.
real kicker for finland though is that you can only sell 3g phones tied to network deals(used to be that you couldn't tie anything to a network sub). also goes for any other small country, apple unlikely to even enter those markets if they want to keep the exclusivity/revenue share model... (not that there is a lot to share in properly competed markets anyhow)
derX @ Oct 6th 2007 7:13PM
BEST.
DISCLAIMER.
EVER.
Doug Tondro @ Oct 7th 2007 9:35PM
BEST.
MOBILE PHONE LAWS.
EVER.
OS2Guy @ Oct 8th 2007 12:11PM
Gee, it's too too bad the French won't be getting the iPhone. They claim to be the country of fashion and style but their failure to protect the iPhone will leave them without it.
OTOH, Italy, Germany, England, Aussieland and all of Euro *will* be sporting around their own iPhones.
Ha Ha!