
Following yesterday's surprising announcement that
patent troll firm NTP is taking portable computing pioneer Palm to court over alleged IP infringement, the PDA and smartphone manufacturer has fired back with a statement detailing its position on the matter. While Palm corroborates NTP's assertion that the latter company had previously approached it about licensing the patents in question, it points out that all seven of them are still undergoing re-examination by the US Patent and Trademark Office, and all signs point to them being ruled invalid once the inquiry is complete. Therefore, Sunnyvale-based Palm has promised to "defend itself vigorously against the attempted misuse of the patent and judicial systems," which is the diplomatic way of saying that NTP won't see one red cent unless they pry it from Palm's cold, dead hands. Since the
RIM / NTP fiasco took quite some time to wind its way through the courts, it seems that Palm is making the smart move here by stringing this along until the USPTO makes its final decision, but there's one thing it needs to bear in mind: NTP's got
half a billion dollars to blow on legal fees, and since it doesn't actually do anything besides sue people, it can focus all of its energy and resources on this amusing but unhealthy lawsuit addiction.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
MAS90Guru @ Nov 8th 2006 5:42AM
I hear that another company had a similar lawsuit a while ago. They also said that the patents were invalid. Turns out they were right. No -- wait! Actually turned out they paid millions to make the problem go away.
Gotta love the USA patent laws.
Pretty soon NTP will run out of profitable companies to attack.
badonkadonk @ Nov 8th 2006 1:35PM
If you want to get technical, NTP has less than a quarter of a billion to "blow on legal fees" given that the $650M was awarded three ways to the two founders of NTP (or their respective widows) and the shareholders of the company - it would only be the latter group's money that could be used on new lawsuits.
That being said, when RIM paid them off, they received an unfettered license to the technology, which extends to the BlackBerry service running on other devices as well (eg: BBConnect on your Palm 650). I don't even see how Palm can be in violation of their patents since Palm doesn't have their own push email system (or do they? I've never used one but always though you needed to get Good or Visto or something).
bah - whatever, I'll check back on this story in four years.